Jeraldine Phneah
No Result
View All Result
  • About
  • Start Here
  • Work
  • Learn
  • Money
  • Family
  • Wellbeing
  • Environment
SUBSCRIBE
  • About
  • Start Here
  • Work
  • Learn
  • Money
  • Family
  • Wellbeing
  • Environment
Jeraldine Phneah
No Result
View All Result

What are some flaws which makes the Singapore education system so stressful?

in Learn
Reading Time: 7 mins read
35.4k 1.5k
Home Learn
36.9k
VIEWS

There has been a lot of talk and concern about the inherent flaws of the Singapore education system which cause it to be too stressful for our children.

Earlier this week, there was a CNA video of the life of a primary 6 student preparing for PSLE that went viral with over 11,000 shares on Facebook.

Another blog post that went viral was titled “What are we doing to our children?” written by Blogger Ian Tan. He shared his concerns about this worrying trend and hoped that for the children for our next generation, we will not

“inculcate in them that a person should spend his life obsessing about results, money or what people think of them via status symbols”.

I’d be worried too if I look at the statistics on private tuition expenses.

In 2015, a Household Expenditure Survey revealed that families here spent $1.1 billion per year on tuition. This is almost double the $650 million spent 10 years ago and one-third more than the $820 million spent just five years ago.

While many were quick to blame the parents for being “overly competitive”, I feel it is unfair to put the blame on them.

I do acknowledge that there are some parents who are being unnecessarily ‘kiasu’ and using their child’s accomplishments to boost their own self-esteem or lack thereof.

However, I believe that the stressful Singapore Education System is a bigger contributing factor.

As someone who just graduated from university and entered the workforce, let me share my insights on why:

 

1. Grades are important for the biggest employer in Singapore

No matter how our government tries to appease the masses by saying things like “every school is a good school” and “grades are not the focus”, it doesn’t change the reality about Singapore that grades are extremely important for some jobs in the future.

Just take the civil service for an example which is the biggest employer in Singapore.

When one applies for a government job, you will be asked to list your O and A level results and the specific grade you got for each subject. This is despite the fact that such exams are taken really long ago like when one is 16 and 18 respectively. Not only that, you have to bring photocopies of these documents on your first interview.

The civil service also perceives the level of honours you get as an important factor in deciding whether or not to hire you and promote you in the future.

In fact, if you’re from a private university like the SIM Global Education program, your chances of qualifying for the civil service is lower than those from NUS, NTU and SMU.

In contrast, most companies in the private sector especially the leading ones couldn’t care less about your O level and A level scores.

Times have changed and when hiring fresh graduates, many of the top firms prefer to focus on other more important factors such as internships, community service, overseas exposure etc.

I’ve been to a few interviews and not a single employer asked for my GPA, much less my O level and A level results. In my first job at a British MNC, the HR department didn’t ask for my degree till there was a recent degree scam incident in Singapore earlier this year.

Sadly, the civil service is the main and biggest employer in Singapore. Thus, their hiring practices no matter how ridiculous would influence the mindset of the youth.

 

2. The Bell Curve System

In Singapore’s education system today, it is not enough to just do well in your grades. You have to do better comparatively to others. This is due to the bell curve system.

Say if you get 85/100 for your test but majority of your classmates get 90/100, you will probably end up with a B4.

Thus, in order to out-compete their child’s classmates, Singaporean parents spend money on tuition to help their child remain competitive.

It is like an arms race where one is forever trying to be in the top ten percentile. Those whose parents can’t afford tuition will get left behind.

 


3. Competition from foreign students

Perhaps there was a bell-curve system in place during the 80s and 90s. However, it was a lot less stressful as kids just have to compete with Singaporeans.

The children today are competing with several talented and bright students from ASEAN, China and India.

In 2012, there were 51,000 foreign students in government-run schools and institutions. This makes up roughly 8 percent of all the students here.

These students tend to be extremely hardworking because in general…

  • They may come from a country which may have fewer opportunities and have to make the most out of educational opportunities they’ve gotten
  • They are also not obliged to spend time with family given that their family is not in Singapore
  • Their education system is better than Singapore in some ways. For instance, China’s education system is more advanced in mathematics and Mandarin than in Singapore. Thus, they can tackle these subjects easily here.

Since we have the bell curve system, local students must thus work harder to keep up with new ‘foreign talents’ in order to get a distinction. This is because the presence of foreign competition is significant enough to affect a child’s grades. For example, a student who might have gotten an A without foreign students now gets a B.

A good example will be my personal experience. When I was 16, I took Higher Chinese and my grades were moderated with students from China. As a result, I got a D7. In contrast, my friends taking Higher Malay and Tamil didn’t have this disadvantage given that there was no competition from Tamil Nadu etc.

One year later, I took A level Chinese. I scored a distinction easily without even putting in extra effort. This was because I was competing with Singaporean students and not the top ones from China.

 

4. Tuition centres teach exam hacks which schools don’t 

 

As someone who had tuition for a few subjects in school, I personally believe that the materials and teaching from tuition centres are sometimes better than those offered in school.

Firstly, while schools teach content, tuition centres put a lot more effort on exam hacks, teaching you how to game the system and score more with less effort.

With Economics tuition from Caravan Tuition at Novena, I scored an A for and was second place. This is because while others spent time studying the content, I placed 80 percent of my time on studying how the marking process worked and what type of answers examiners wanted from

This is because while others spent time studying the content, I placed 80 percent of my time on studying how the marking process worked and what type of answers examiners wanted from specific type of questions which helped me get an A.

A tuition teacher often has many contacts and can get notes and materials from top junior colleges and secondary schools. So for instance if a neighbourhood secondary school student may not receive very good guidance in his school, he can benefit from tuition as the teachers would be able to share resources and tips from better schools with him.

Thankfully, we’re seeing the rise of apps like Snapask. These apps allow students from secondary school and junior colleges to take photos of questions they find difficult and get answers.

I think this disruption in the private tuition is positive because it ultimately levels the playing field. Students from poorer families who can’t afford so much private tuition now can find a cheaper method of getting help for their exam preparation.

 

5. The Singapore education syllabus is getting harder each year 

For some strange reason, the syllabus is getting tougher and tougher with children being made to learn content that is way beyond our years.

We already have the most challenging syllabus globally. Why do you think our kids do so well in the International Baccalaureate (IB) compared to the rest of the world?  This is because our formal education system is much harder than the rest of the world and our GCE A levels and O levels is much tougher than the ones the British take.

However, the Singapore education system seems to be becoming harder and more stressful for the sake of it without any consideration as to how it can benefit our youth in the future.

Does introducing so much content and such a level of difficulty in our subjects really improve our workforce and build leaders of tomorrow? I disagree.

Instead, I believe the free time could be spent on developing soft skills and inculcating creativity instead. Scientific studies have shown that a relaxed mind is absolutely necessary for developing creativity.

As Jack Ma said “I told my son: you don’t need to be in the top three in your class, being in the middle is fine, so long as your grades aren’t too bad. Only this kind of person [a middle-of-the-road student] has enough free time to learn other skills.”

True enough, with the exception of Baidu’s Robin Li, many of China’s top internet executives achieved their success despite not having been “top three”-type students.

If you look at the corporate world in Singapore, it is mostly the people from Western countries who are on top. Why? Other than the fact that  many of our local people somehow perceive westerners as superior, these guys generally also possess the necessary soft skills for thriving in the workplace.

Heck, most of them are not even from schools that are ranked as highly as NUS or NTU.

Education

The state of education in Singapore is worrying. As mentioned in my previous article 5 Differences between neighbourhood and elite schools, it is not equitable and no longer facilitates social mobility like how it used to.

Also, the Singapore education system is not delivering what the job market needs. Why is it that when Singaporeans emerge from this education system and enter the workforce, they are deemed as not having the right set of skills? That is like making students go through so much hardship with little rewards in the future in proportion to the effort they put in. Is it smart to leave it in the hands of bureaucrats who have little or almost zero private sector experience to know what the market wants?

If you agree with the analysis here, like this post and share it with your friends. What are your thoughts? Share your views below!

SendShareShare14765Share2584
Previous Post

Why Is LinkedIn So Important For Millennials

Next Post

What ‘Finding Dory’ Teaches Us About Protecting Our Oceans

Related Posts

5 Persuasion Hacks based on with Behavioral Economics – Irrational Labs Review
Learn

5 Persuasion Hacks based on with Behavioral Economics – Irrational Labs Review

2k
What Millennials can learn about success & happiness from Clayton Christensen
Learn

What Millennials can learn about success & happiness from Clayton Christensen

1.4k
How can Private University Graduates overcome discrimination?
Learn

How can Private University Graduates overcome discrimination?

12.9k
Why elitism in Singapore exists & how to change it
Learn

Why elitism in Singapore exists & how to change it

35.8k
Philip Yeo Book
Learn

5 Leadership Lessons from Former EDB Chairman Philip Yeo – A Book Review

23.2k
Is It Disadvantageous To Graduate From A Private University In Singapore?
Learn

Is It Disadvantageous To Graduate From A Private University In Singapore?

62.2k
Load More
Next Post
Finding Dory

What 'Finding Dory' Teaches Us About Protecting Our Oceans

The Case For Mandatory Eldercare Leave In Singapore

The Case For Mandatory Eldercare Leave In Singapore

jeraldinephneah

Today is the start of a new quarter for me. I spen Today is the start of a new quarter for me. I spent my CNY holiday taking a break and reflecting on life. I also had a chance to have deep conversations with some friends to correct some false beliefs holding me back.

For the past few years, I think I’ve done quite a good job with prioritising my physical health, and being someone who has gotten their finances/work in order. It is time to focus more on building myself internally.

This quarter onwards, I aim to start taking life a little slower; stop trying to distract myself with so many activities; spend more time on self-reflection and focus inwards a little more.
Buying 春联 for my house and supporting @grassro Buying 春联 for my house and supporting @grassrootsbookroom and @leeter_tunku_kopitiam

They will be selling calligraphy every Sunday till 30 Jan 😊
Mosburger by the bay Mosburger by the bay
I've always had a clear idea of what I wanted and I've always had a clear idea of what I wanted and a specific strategy on how I was going to get there.

I thought I had my life planned out in my 20s and going exactly the way I wanted. Yet at 30, the ENTJ in me has begun to accept that there is a limit to how much I can plan.

Even the most well-thought plan is powerless against the uncertainties and curveballs in life.

We cannot control every single thing, but what I've learned is that three things are essential.

1. Hope/Optimism - life is constantly changing whether we want it or not. Sometimes, we win and sometimes we lose. Yet, these losses are meant to direct us down a path that is better for us. 

2. To learn - to treat each setback as a learning opportunity and continually work on being the best person you can be for yourself and the people around you. 

3. Choice - you cannot control your fate but you can alter your destiny by choosing how to respond and focusing on how you can turn challenges into an advantage.

Looking forward to 2022 and what life has to bring 😊
Our team of SDRs, BDR, AE (myself) and Solution En Our team of SDRs, BDR, AE (myself) and Solution Engineer finally met in person ytd evening!

One thing which makes me grateful about being at Workato is having a strong supportive team and a good boss (not in this picture).

When it comes to working with our team, I go by 4 principles which I share with everyone.

1. Alignment - I will aim to provide visibility into overall plan; my schedule and progress

2. Open Communication - I will be tactful, candid and two-way. Please hold me accountable and provide direct feedback when you feel I can do better. This is inspired by @raydalio principles on radical candor. 

3. Care - I will strive to engage you on a personal level and with generosity, authenticity, and vulnerability.

4. Empowerment - No one is too junior to share ideas, speak up in meetings with customers and contribute ideas. We all have something valuable to bring to the table as long as we put our customers’ interest first.

#kakīlâng #家己人 #workato
Follow on Instagram
This error message is only visible to WordPress admins
There has been a problem with your Instagram Feed.

© 2021 Jeraldine Phneah

No Result
View All Result
  • About
  • Start Here
  • Work
  • Learn
  • Money
  • Family
  • Wellbeing
  • Environment

© 2021 Jeraldine Phneah

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Add New Playlist

Are you sure want to unlock this post?
Unlock left : 0
Are you sure want to cancel subscription?